After years of advocating the abolition of frozen rental contracts, the Lisbon Landlords Association (ALP) has just launched a public petition demanding that the Government and parties with seats in parliament “immediately end” the freeze on old rents. As of 10:45 am this Tuesday, the petition had collected around 300 signatures, with at least 7,500 needed for the petition to be discussed in the plenary session of the Assembly of the Republic, according to a report by ECO.
In a statement, the association believes that the “secular conditioning of the national rental market (…) prolongs the agony of all landlords who, forced by the State, have maintained rental contracts for over 40 years”, as well as “generations of tenants who are forced into debt, due to the reduction in the supply of houses for rent in large cities at fair prices”.
In addition to the immediate abolition of the rent freeze, the ALP calls for an “urgent” and “sensible” extraordinary update of the frozen rents starting next year, a request supported, in the petition, with a proposal to adopt a new calculation formula for calculating these rents “currently with very low values”.
The Lisbon landlords justify the request with the fact that the current mechanism for calculating frozen rents, in force since 2012, “results in values that are up to ten times less than the metrics practiced in the affordable rental programs that are promoted and supported by the State”. This mechanism “harms owners who have effectively been putting up with frozen leases at very low values for decades”, which is explained “by the fact that the properties of these owners necessarily have a negligible taxable property value, due to the coefficient of the age of the properties applied”, argues the ALP in the statement.
Well done! This is the sort of mess that results when Socialist governments interfere with free markets. If you control rents, no-one is going to want to invest in property and provide accommodation, making life far harder for prospective tenants. Policy should be dictated by common sense and practicality, not dogma or bigotry.
The same would happen if you controlled the prices an electrician could charge for their labour. No-one would want to be one or remain one, and it would be difficult to find an electrician.
Why don't governments trust the people, but instead feel they must control (and wreck) everything?
By Billy Bissett from Porto on 27 Aug 2024, 11:03
This is the stupidest thing I've ever read. Who cares what greedy landlords want, they've had it too good for too long. All investments carry risk, they've been bleeding workers dry taking 2/3rds of workers (horrifically underpaid in lisbon) wages for years.
They don't produce anything. They don't create housing they horde it. This is not a luxury good, people need somewhere to live, landlords are parasites.
Why is Portugal news reporting on 300 greedy idiots wanting to make more money, newsflash water is wet.
Why not interview the many struggling young people who can barely get by? If only for a pretense of balance. Why are you manufacturing consent for these predators.
By Tobias from Lisbon on 27 Aug 2024, 20:02
Even America, the land of free enterprise, has rent controls. I cannot see how removing rent controls would improve the situation, beyond making landlords richer of course.
By David Pursey from Algarve on 29 Aug 2024, 08:36
Yess very good desition for country
By Shafi Uddin from Lisbon on 31 Aug 2024, 13:17
Yes. Those rent controls destroyed Lisboa in the past. Property owners didn't receive enough to maintain the properties, yet government did nothing to maintain and subsidize. That's the reason Lisboa was a dangerous pig pen. Now, it's a place to be appreciated and a place to be proud of. This is why the masses come, enjoy and invest. Tobias is right in that Portuguese workers earn too little and should earn more, so they can enjoy and cover their expenses. But he is wrong in implying no one should care for the property owners. Many owners used there hard earned money to buy an investment property to help subsidize their old age. They are not rich, and many saved and sacrificed so they can invest. They didn't waste their entire paycheck for momentary pleasure. To say they don't matter is pure ignorance. Learn a bit more about economics and how everything is intertwined before you speak!
By Dave G. from USA on 05 Sep 2024, 09:33